Blackouts, currency dives and corruption: Pakistan’s economy is on the brink of collapse

The crisis Pakistan finds itself in was a long time in the making, and goes far beyond electoral politics, people who study the country say.

“Pakistan’s economic situation is a direct reflection of the misplaced priorities of the country for decades,” said Kamal Madishetty, a researcher at the Institute of Peace and Conflict Studies in New Delhi. He pointed to the overwhelming control of the military over all other institutions as a key factor.

“The country’s military establishment continues to corner a disproportionate share of resources for itself, at the expense of ordinary citizens,” he said, explaining that in 2022, as Pakistan cut spending on areas like infrastructure and education, military spending ballooned by 11%. 

“The public discourse may pin the economic difficulties on one government after another, but those really responsible are the class of people permanently in power.”

Kamal Alam, a non-resident senior fellow at the Atlantic Council, described a dysfunctional ruling class that for decades has misappropriated funds and prevented meaningful reform. 

“Mired in political, military, feudal corruption, Pakistan has now existed as a state that only survives due to the largesse of the Saudis, China, UAE and the U.S. in that order,” he said. “But finally its patrons have also run out of patience due to lack of transparency of the impact of their actual donations.”

Oil-rich Saudi Arabia has been a longtime ally of Pakistan, coming to its aid financially numerous times. But now even the Saudis are demanding to see serious improvement concerning governance and corruption before it loosens its purse strings. 

More recently, Pakistan has been a victim of climate change: catastrophic floods in June of 2022 put one-third of the country underwater, affecting 33 million people and causing billions of dollars of damage and economic loss. 

That combined with the already existing economic problems and the enduring impact of Covid-19 led the World Bank in early January to lower the country’s growth projections from 4% last June to 2% for 2023, citing “precarious economic situation, low foreign exchange reserves and large fiscal and current account deficits” as key reasons.

Pakistan is also close to China – and deeply in its debt. More than 30% of Pakistan’s total foreign debt is owed to China, according to the IMF. That’s three times what Pakistan owes the IMF and more than its loans from the World Bank and Asian Development Bank combined, says Madishetty.

These Chinese loans, he said, “are accompanied by opaque conditionalities, overlook long-term viability of projects, ignore environmental and social costs, and have interest rates that are usually 1-2 percent higher than those offered by OECD lenders.” 

Despite all this and its current financial situation, Pakistan continues to borrow from China.

“Most recently, it has sought a $10 billion loan from China for a major railway project, ignoring debt concerns. Such decisions certainly push the country towards defaulting on its debt sooner rather than later,” Madishetty said. 

Alam says that China’s debt is actually “the least of Pakistan’s problems, given the Chinese Pakistan alliance is primarily military and in that sense different to African states or other Southeast Asian states.” The two countries need each other for military and strategic purposes, so debt to China may not be as urgent a liability yet as the rest of the country’s issues.

For Usman, the photographer in Islamabad, the pressure to leave — for those who have the means, or relatives overseas — is becoming more and more real. 

“It’s all been a blur,” he said. “My sister called the night after the blackout asking me to renew my parents’ passports. She wants them to leave Pakistan and come to Canada.”