Cryptocurrency IRAs: Advantages and Disadvantages

Cryptocurrency IRA: An Overview

There is no specific Individual Retirement Account (IRA) recognized by the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) designed for cryptocurrencies. Thus, when you hear about a “cryptocurrency IRA” or “Bitcoin IRA,” it is an IRA that allows you to include digital currencies within its portfolio of holdings.

Since 2014, the IRS has taxed cryptocurrencies as property, meaning they are taxed in the same fashion as stocks, bonds, or other investment types. Like the other investments, they cannot be placed into an IRA by the account holder. This means that if you want to put crypto in your IRA, you must enlist the help of a custodian.

The issue you’ll run into is that finding a custodian who will custody crypto assets for you in an IRA can be challenging. Fortunately, self-directed IRAs (SDIRAs) more frequently allow for alternative assets like cryptocurrencies.

Custodians and other companies designed to help investors include cryptocurrency in their IRAs have become increasingly popular. Some examples are BitIRA, Equity Trust, and Bitcoin IRA, one of the early leaders in the field.

Key Takeaways

• A cryptocurrency IRA is an IRA with cryptocurrencies in its portfolio.
• To the IRS, cryptocurrencies are considered and taxed as property.
• A few advantages of cryptocurrencies are that they diversify portfolios, are expected by some to grow in popularity and availability, and may benefit investors with favorable tax treatment.
• A few disadvantages include hefty fees, extreme volatility, and significant risk.

The Advantages of Cryptocurrency IRAs

Despite their negative connotations, cryptocurrencies have several advantages that could help your IRA grow.

Diversification

You may find that including cryptocurrency holdings can add diversification to retirement portfolios. This may help to protect those retirement accounts in the event of a major market downturn or other tumultuous activity in the future.

Growth Potential

Perhaps more than diversification, investors inclined to add crypto holdings to their IRAs likely believe that cryptocurrencies will continue to grow in popularity and accessibility into the future. With their long-term outlook, IRAs are an excellent vehicle for investments with significant potential over decades.

Important

Growth potential is accompanied by a significant risk of losses. However, some investors feel that the possibility of growth outweighs the risks, especially if the risks are accounted for in the portfolio’s strategy.

Tax Strategies

If you’re determined to invest in cryptocurrency, avoiding hefty capital gains taxes may be possible by including digital currencies in retirement accounts using a tax strategy. For example, placing cryptocurrency in a Roth IRA lets you realize any capital gains without being taxed since you already paid taxes on the funds in the account.

If you place your crypto in a regular IRA, you pay income taxes when you make a withdrawal. This could give you a tax advantage if your income—and possibly your tax bracket—is reduced after you begin withdrawing from your IRA.

Taxes for trading within your regular IRA are the same as trading stocks in one—you don’t pay taxes on profitable trades, only when you make a withdrawal. Trading crypto from a Roth IRA would receive the same tax treatment as holding it in one.

The Disadvantages of Cryptocurrency IRAs

Price Volatility

For many, extreme volatility makes cryptocurrency a tough sell as a retirement investment. For example, the leading cryptocurrency, Bitcoin, routinely experiences significant price fluctuations; since 2009, it has gone from virtually no value and varied everywhere from about $16,000 to nearly $75,000. This makes it unsuitable for someone approaching retirement who needs stable and liquid assets; however, it might make sense for someone who has decades before they retire.

Risk

Volatility brings the risk of loss in the form of large swings in value. For example, if you purchased a cryptocurrency for $1,000, its price could fall more than 75% over a few months and never recover. In this case, you’d lose $750—larger investments would amplify the losses.

Many cryptocurrencies are not backed by businesses or assets, so they may lose the interest of the public and investors after you purchase them. Most are only supported by the belief that they are worth something—if that belief ever wavers on a large scale, cryptocurrencies could collapse and take billions of dollars with them.

Account and Trading Fees

Another key disadvantage of including crypto in an IRA is the fees. Crypto trading through an IRA differs from regular stock trading or trading at cryptocurrency exchanges, which are not custodians.

Because broker fiduciary duties do not bind firms offering self-directed IRA services, it is your responsibility to assess the risks associated with crypto markets and take measures to mitigate them.

Fees for crypto trading take on various forms during the investment process. They range from initial setup fees to custody, trading, or annual maintenance fees. For example, setting up a $50,000 self-directed IRA account for trading can cost several thousand dollars in charges during an initial setup, depending on the provider. There are also recurring custody and maintenance fees charged by providers of these services.

Finally, each cryptocurrency trade incurs fees from the service provider’s trading partner and custodian. A typical provider may charge 3.5% per transaction per purchase and 1% or a flat fee for each sale. Additionally, you may be on the hook for blockchain processing fees if they’re not included in regular charges.

Special Considerations

Cryptocurrency has unique requirements, such as security or custody, which tend to bump fees up for services offered through IRA accounts. IRA custodians working with cryptocurrency must also be prepared to take on additional reporting duties with the IRS—this could translate into even more fees for cryptocurrency IRA investors.

When looking for a custodian to execute your crypto wishes, you’ll find plenty of scams or fraudulent companies offering services. The U.S. Commodities Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) warned about false crypto IRA companies claiming they had IRS approval. The Securities and Exchange Commission has also issued alerts about fraudulent cryptocurrency IRAs.

If you’re in the market for a crypto IRA, it’s best to speak with a certified financial advisor familiar with cryptocurrency to ensure your money is being put to its best use.

Can You Withdraw From a Crypto IRA?

Yes. You can make cryptocurrency withdrawals from an IRA, but they are subject to the same taxation rules as other funds in the IRA.

Is There an IRA for Crypto?

You can place crypto in some self-directed IRAs. Whether you can purchase them with your IRA depends on your broker.

How Is a Crypto IRA Taxed?

Assets held within self-directed IRAs are subject to the same tax rates as other funds or assets in the IRA. So, it depends on the type of IRA and when you’re attempting to make a withdrawal. Traditional IRAs are taxed at ordinary income tax rates upon withdrawal, and Roth IRA contributions are taxed as ordinary income before deposit, with no taxes at withdrawal.

The Bottom Line

Purchasing cryptocurrency through your IRA is one way to diversify your portfolio if you can tolerate the risks involved with the possibility of gains. There might also be tax advantages to holding cryptocurrency in your IRA, so it’s best to talk to a financial advisor familiar with IRAs and cryptocurrency to see if it is an option for you.

The comments, opinions, and analyses expressed on Investopedia are for informational purposes only. Read our warranty and liability disclaimer for more info. As of the date this article was written, the author owns BTC, ETH, ADA, and XRP.

Read the original article on Investopedia.